What do you do leftover pumpkin puree that you don’t use? Whether its puree from a can or puree from fresh pumpkins, you can preserve pumpkin puree in 5 easy steps

Ok, I know what you are thinking!

Its not hard to figure out why you are scratching your head as you read the title and description of this post

Front View of Pumpkin Puree Ice Cubes on a Silver Tray with Mint Leaves for Garnish - How to Preserve Pumpkin Puree

“Why preserve pumpkin puree when its available year round?”

“What’s the point of saving it?”

Ok, those are valid questions, I agree.  However, you probably haven’t experienced a very real-life scenario I found myself in a couple of years ago.

Sit back and let me take you down the proverbial memory lane.

Closeup View of Pumpkin Puree Ice Cubes on a Silver Tray with Mint Leaves for Garnish - How to Preserve Pumpkin Puree

It was October 2016.  The humidity was starting to loose its control over Florida and that was inspiring me to experiment.  The need-to-try-new-experiment itch started right after I had just finished making my savory pumpkin dip.

Halloween wasn’t too far away and Thanksgiving would arrive before I could say, “Holy pumpkin season, Batman!”

I opened 4 cans of pumpkin puree and started creating all kinds of recipes.  This recipes eventually (by eventually, I mean 1 year later when pumpkins were back in fashion) came to the blog in the form of Pumpkin Soup, Pumpkin Smoothies and Pumpkin Pasta.  There was a even a curry recipe but that will never see the light of day!

(Ok, never say never, right! It MAY come to the blog after I have perfected the recipe?)

After all the experimenting, I still had plenty of pumpkin puree left over and just couldn’t let it go to waste.

Overhead View of Pumpkin Puree Ice Cubes on a Silver Tray with Mint Leaves for Garnish - How to Preserve Pumpkin Puree

The one thing all my experimental recipes had in common was that I used coconut milk along with pumpkin puree. So, i felt the proverbial light bulb went off above my head.

If I have left over Pumpkin puree and leftover coconut milk and they get along so well, why not mix them?!

I pulled out my trusted blender and dumped both leftovers into it.  When the blender was turned on, the orange colors and white swirls flew up in the blender doing a dance that would make the NYC Ballet proud!

Eventually, the color turned into a harmonious light orange, which reminded me of a quite sunset on a cool fall evening.

I dropped the beautiful orange liquid into ice cube trays, covered it with plastic wrap and let it freeze to perfection!

As the months went by, I would plop them into various recipes giving the meal just a slight flavoring of the holiday season.  Can you imagine feeling like its Thanksgiving all year round?

Angle View of Pumpkin Puree Liquid in Blue Ice Cube Tray - How to Preserve Pumpkin Puree

This preserving method was the best idea I ever had, if I say so myself.  I would have hated to throw it away or have it go bad.

Here are a few things to keep in mind when preserving it:

– Don’t preserve the puree by itself.  It turns crumbly when you ‘defrost’ it.  Always preserve pumpkin puree with some liquid such as water or pumpkin juice (1:2 ratio).  If you are a heavy consumer of coconut milk, you love this combination, am I right?

– Don’t forget to cover it with plastic wrap.  This will prevent the top from getting a ‘freezer burn’ look.  If you had freezer burn, you know its not a good feeling, so, don’t subject the puree to it either.  I have also seen (affiliate link) ice cube trays with silicone cover.  They will work too.

– Preserving them in ice cube form makes it easier to use in recipes instead of freezing the whole amount into one container

So, next time you have leftover pumpkin puree, you know exactly what to do with it!  The best part is that you can use it all year round.

Now that you know how to preserve pumpkin puree, what recipe will you be using it in?

Closeup View of Pumpkin Puree Ice Cubes on a Silver Tray with Mint Leaves for Garnish

My Favorite Way To Preserve Pumpkin Puree

Blend pumpkin puree and coconut milk, then freeze it in ice cube tray
5 from 2 votes
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 5 minutes
Total Time 15 minutes
Course Ingredient
Cuisine American
Servings 3 cups
Calories 324 kcal



  • In a blender, add both ingredients
  • Blend on high speed until well blended
  • Transfer to ice cube trays (I used 2 ice cube trays)
  • Wrap the whole tray in plastic wrap and place in the freezer
  • Leave it overnight to freeze completely


– Use the 1:2 ratio when preserving pumpkin puree, meaning use double the liquid you are using with the pumpkin
– You can add other ingredients that you might use with the pumpkin recipe.  For example, I put some mint leaves in a few of the ice cubes.  They make for great smoothies.  For me, however, having only 2 ingredients was better because I could use it in any recipe. 


Serving: 3cupsCalories: 324kcalCarbohydrates: 10gProtein: 3gFat: 32gSaturated Fat: 28gSodium: 23mgPotassium: 499mgFiber: 2gSugar: 2gVitamin A: 12710IUVitamin C: 5mgCalcium: 48mgIron: 6.1mg
Keyword can you preserve pumpkin puree, what to do with leftover pumpkin puree
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

Similar Posts

5 from 2 votes (1 rating without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.