This homemade pumpkin pie spice is an aromatic and easy blend to make at home. I put a little twist on the traditional recipe by including 2 extra ingredients in my pumpkin spice blend

I am one of those people who never understood why everyone loves PSL!

All that changed last year when I had my very first taste of a PSL latte. WOW! I can’t believe I have been missing out.

This year, I have made it my mission to enjoy everything with pumpkin pie spice!

That means I better learn to make my own or my spice mission will get very expensive

closeup view of the hand ground seasoning in a mortar and pestle

Tips for making this spice

  • Place the mortar and pestle on the ground or floor because it will be so much easier to grind the ingredients.
  • I try to use whole spices instead of their powdered counterparts because the difference in taste and aroma is very distinctive.
  • As with my creole seasoning and any homemade seasoning, I make sure I store it in a glass jar with an air-tight seal.
  • I used a mortar and pestle to ground all the whole spices (except for the ginger powder). It was a little extra work, but, definitely worth it.
  • Use up this batch of homemade pumpkin pie spice this season because it will go stale by next year.
  • If you have easy access to an Indian store, buy whole nutmeg from there. It will be cheaper.
closeup view of ground pumpkin spice in a mortar and pestle with the words "FALL" written out with ingredients

What’s pumpkin pie spice?

Pumpkin pie spice is made by blending several spices together. These spices are everyday spices and can be easily found in any pantry

As you guessed from the name, pumpkin pie spice is the spice used to flavor pumpkin pies. No matter what kind of pumpkin pie you make, this spice will always be present.

closeup view of ground pumpkin spice in a mortar and pestle

Why I like making my own

In my area, store bought pumpkin spice is about $6 for a 1-2 oz bottle! That is way to expensive, especially for a spice that I use for only 3 months out of the year.

So, now, I know what you are probably thinking! Isn’t it more expensive to buy all the ingredients to make this pumpkin pie spice at home?

Yes, the total comes out to just under $30 to buy all the ingredients needed to make this spice at home. I can hear the wheels turning in your head as you try to calculate the difference between $6 and $30, lol!

closeup view of ground pumpkin spice in a mortar and pestle

Here is why I consider it to be cheaper to make it at home. I can use the same ingredients in other recipes or other homemade spices. Pretty cool, right?

In the end, its much cheaper to DIY pumpkin pie spice from scratch. Do you agree?

Now, my head hurts from all the math! Excuse me while I go take a nap. 🙂

Common questions when making this spice

closeup view of ground pumpkin spice in a mortar and pestle

As you grind this pumpkin pie spice, you might think of some questions. “Why is it so expensive?”, “Can it go bad?” and other questions.

Below, I answer some common questions. Feel free to ask other questions in the comments below

Why is it so expensive to buy?

From what I understand, the type of cinnamon used determines the price of the Pumpkin Pie Spice.
If Ceylon cinnamon is used in the spice, then its bound to be expensive. Ceylon cinnamon is the “true cinnamon” and comes from Sri Lanka. This is the stuff that is expensive and it makes our pumpkin spice be pricey
Source: Bon Appetit and my own experience

Can this spice go bad?

Store bought pumpkin pie spice does loose its strong aromas quickly. I have noticed that I should use it up within a month of buying it.
Those companies that store it in glass bottles will have a longer shelf life. The one sold in plastic bottles loose their potency very quickly, in my experience
My homemade version lasts about 2 months, if I store it in a glass jar with an air-tight container.
This pumpkin pie spice is vegan friendly, so, use it in all your vegan desserts. I wrote up a nifty guide to what is vegan and what is not vegan.

How do I make pumpkin pie spice from scratch?

Blend these ingredients together:
– Nutmeg
– Cloves
– Cinnamon Sticks
– All Spice
– Star Anise
– Cardamom
– Ginger Powder

What can I use this spice in?

My favorite way to use this spice is in my olive oil cake! It’s makes the cake taste so good. If you are on a Keto diet, then Trina Krug has an easy keto pumpkin pie recipe that is so good. She use pumpkin pie spice that gives it a unique flavor. Recently, I made these homemade pumpkin spice bagels using this spice and they turned out so delicious!

Why use a mortar and pestle to make it?

Growing up, we always saw our spices and flours ground by hand. We loved watching family members sit around the kitchen and grind ingredients.
Ginger, garlic, chili, cinnamon, cloves, cardamon, cumin, coriander seeds and so many ingredients were hand ground. They would be stored and be used for months to come.
If you find dried ginger, use it in this recipe. Ground ginger has so much more aroma and flavor.
For me, grinding spices is very natural and its also a way to pay homage to all that came before me that used the mortar and pestle to make food. I find that food tastes more authentic when it the ingredients are hand ground.

Recipes that use this spice blend

The next time a recipe calls for pumpkin spice, pull out your mortar and pestle to make it. Your recipe will have that wonderful homemade taste.

Why pay $6-$8 for pumpkin spice latte when you can make your own, right?

My favorite recipe to make using this pumpkin pie spice is a rustic vegan apple pie recipe, strawberry cupcakes, butternut squash pie, and a blueberry galette! It flavored the pie so well and tasted delicious.

closeup view of ground spice in a mortar and pestle with a spoon in it

Sharing is caring

Don’t be shy, chime in below in the comments. Let me hear your opinion on this recipe. If you enjoyed this, please give it 5 stars and share it on Facebook, Pinterest, Twitter, Instagram and Youtube.

⭐️ Want even more Healing Tomato recipes? Sign up for my weekly newsletter ⭐️

closeup view of ground pumpkin pie spice in a mortar and pestle

How to make Pumpkin Pie Spice

Quickly blend a few spices to make a this homemade pumpkin pie spice. I love using my mortar and pestle to grind the ingredients.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 1 minute
Cook Time 20 minutes
Total Time 21 minutes
Course Ingredient
Cuisine American
Servings 1 person
Calories 95 kcal




  • Place the nutmeg in the mortar and pestle (see notes)
  • Grind it to powder consistency
  • Add the cloves on top of the ground nutmeg
  • Grind the cloves until its a fine powder
  • Continue the process with cinnamon, all spice, cardamom and ginger powder
  • Give all the spices one final grind to mix it all together
  • Transfer to a glass spice bottle



  • Nutrition info is approximate
  • Grinding the nutmeg is not going to be easy.  It takes lots of elbow grease and pounding to get it to a find powder.  It took me about 10 minutes to get it really fine.  So, be sure to have patience when blending it. 
  • You can use ground nutmeg too, if you don’t want to blend whole nutmeg
  • Keep the bottle with pumpkin pie spice in the pantry, away from direct sunlight


Calories: 95kcal
Keyword Can you make pumpkin pie spice at home?, Use mortar and pestle to grind spices
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

One Comment